Immortal Eyes
Visual - 5/10 - The layout is broken for me in both Firefox and IE. The site is still viewable at least, and the navigation is easily found.
The images used for title banners for the video could use a little work, some of the them are very grainy or blurry and there's one missing image.
Text and Info - 10/10 - I can't really judge this because this is a video site.
Interactive - 6/10 - There are lots of downloads, it being a MV site and all. Unfortunately, a bunch of the videos are currently down and the "other" downloads page isn't available yet.
Originality - 7/10 - There aren't too many PGSM sites with Music Video sections (the other one that springs to mind is Tsuki Mubi).
Return Factor - 7/10 - When th rotational downloads are up, it provides a reason for visitors to return.
Overall - 35/50 - A decent AMV site that needs some sprucing up.